Character Type, just as Politics, Predicts Who Shares Fake News


Personality Type, as well as Politics, Predicts Who Shares Fake News
Credit: Getty Images
Who shares fake news? Political scientists, behavioral researchers and the media have said that political conservatives are largely responsible for the proliferation of misinformation. But although there is a documented association, not all conservatives share fake news or endorse such behavior. Such sweeping generalizations threaten to condemn everyone who subscribes to conservative values, and that, in turn, risks further and more dangerous polarization.
To find solutions to this misinformation crisis, our society needs a clear-eyed assessment of who and what drives the spread of malicious falsehoods and conspiracy theories. So our research on misinformation sharing has examined another key determinant of individual behavior: personality. There are several systems for identifying and measuring personality traits, but one of the most widely used is the five-factor theory, often called the Big Five. It organizes traits into five categories: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism. Within this framework, we focused specifically on conscientiousness, which captures differences in people’s orderliness, impulse control, conventionality and reliability.
We thought that conscientiousness could help explain the link between political conservatism and sharing fake news. Specifically, we predicted that low-conscientiousness conservatives (LCCs) would disseminate more misinformation than other conservatives or low-conscientiousness liberals. We decided to investigate the relationship between personality, politics, and sharing fake news though a series of eight studies, involving 4,642 participants.

ADVERTISEMENT
First, we measured people’s political ideology and conscientiousness through assessments that asked participants about their values and behaviors. We then showed the same people a series of real and fake news stories relating to COVID and asked them to rate how accurate the stories were. Then we asked whether they would consider sharing each story. We found that both liberals and conservatives sometimes saw false stories as accurate—and this error was likely driven in part by wanting certain stories to be true because they aligned with their beliefs. In addition, people of all political persuasions share false news, but this behavior was markedly higher among LCCs when compared with everyone else in the study. At high levels of conscientiousness, for example, there was no difference between liberals and conservatives. Low-conscientiousness liberals did not share more misinformation than their high-conscientiousness liberal counterparts.
In a second study, we replicated these results with fake news containing a strong political slant and observed an even greater effect. Once again, liberals across the conscientiousness spectrum, along with highly conscientious conservatives, did not engage in spreading misinformation at a high rate. But conservatives low in conscientiousness were frequent spreaders.
We next asked: what explains LCCs’ exceptional tendency to share fake news? To explore this question, we designed an experiment in which we not only gathered information about our participants’ politics and personality, but also administered questionnaires to assess their desire for chaos, support of socially and economically conservative issues, support for Donald Trump, trust in mainstream media, and time spent on social media. LCCs, we learned, expressed a general need for chaos—the desire to disrupt and destroy the existing political and social institutions—and this may explain their greater proclivity to spread misinformation. This need reflects an underlying desire to assert superiority of one’s ideas or group over others and is especially elevated among conservatives with lower conscientiousness. Importantly, other factors we studied, including support for Trump, time spent on social media, and political and economic conservatism were not as strongly tied to LCCs’ heightened tendency to share fake news.
Unfortunately, our work on this personality trait also suggests that accuracy labels on news stories will not solve the problem of misinformation. We ran a study where we explicitly stated whether each news story in question was false, using a “disputed” tag commonly seen on social media, or true, using a “supported” tag. We found that the supported tag increased the rate at which real stories were shared among both liberals and conservatives. However, LCCs continued to share misinformation at a greater rate, despite explicit warnings that the stories were false. Though it’s possible these participants did not believe the fact-check system, the findings support the contention that LCCs share fake news to intentionally sow chaos.
In fact, we ran another study that involved explicitly telling participants that an article they wanted to share was inaccurate. Participants then had the chance to change their answer. Not only did LCCs still share fake news at a higher rate than others in the study, they also were comparatively insensitive to direct warnings that the stories they wanted to share were fake.

Share post on
admin
By admin


Please add "Disqus Shortname" in Customize > Post Settings > Disqus Shortname to enable disqus

BM News is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Recent Comments

No comments to show.
articles

DeepMind AI handles one of science’s most important strategies

A group drove by researchers at the London-based man-made brainpower organization DeepMind has fostered...

By admin
articles

DeepMind AI handles one of science’s most significant procedures

A group drove by researchers at the London-based computerized reasoning organization DeepMind has fostered...

By admin
articles

WNYC Retracts Four Articles on Its News Site, Gothamist

Gothamist, the news site of the New York public radio broadcast WNYC, erased four...

By admin
articles

Examiners remain fixed on setting Maxwell at focus of Epstein’s sex dealing ring

Declaration by the informers offered a nearby glance at Maxwell's essential job in their...

By admin
articles

EXPLAINER: Was Tornado Outbreak Related to Climate Change?

By SUMAN NAISHADHAM and SETH BORENSTEIN, Associated PressWASHINGTON (AP) — The schedule said December...

By admin
articles

‘Science is flawed’: COVID-19, ivermectin, and beyond

Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz is a disease transmission specialist and essayist situated in Sydney, Australia. His...

By admin
articles

World’s top traveler objective on ‘extremely high’ travel hazard list

(CNN) — You all energized for a third year of the pandemic? Nor are...

By admin
articles

Top reports from AMA Morning Rounds®: Week of Dec. 6, 2021

Coronavirus antibody request developing in the midst of Omicron variation fears, extended supporter qualificationThe...

By admin

Latest Posts

Gaming

Privacy Policy – Instant Robux Calculator 2022

This privacy policy applies to Instant Robux Calculator 2022 and all services and products...

By admin
Instructions to Watch the Marvel Netflix Shows all together in 2022 News

Instructions to Watch the Marvel Netflix Shows all together in 2022

The Defenders universe on Netflix has now been closed for north of two years...

By admin
New Spider-Man Theory Suggests MCU Venom Host has Already Appeared 2022 News

New Spider-Man Theory Suggests MCU Venom Host has Already Appeared 2022

The Venom symbiote has formally shown up in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, with a...

By admin
New Pokemon Snap Director Details Game’s Origins News

New Pokemon Snap Director Details Game’s Origins

More than a long time since Pokemon Snap sent off on the Nintendo 64,...

By admin
VanVleet scores season-high 35, Raptors defeat Knicks 120-105 News

VanVleet scores season-high 35, Raptors defeat Knicks 120-105

Fred VanVleet scored 19 of his season-high 35 focuses in the second from last...

By admin
Figure out how to develop games for $20 during our New Year, New You Sale News

Figure out how to develop games for $20 during our New Year, New You Sale

A ton of us love playing computer games, and that can regularly impede doing...

By admin
Samsung’s new brilliant screen can handle your IoT gadgets, stream games, and that’s just the beginning Gaming

Samsung’s new brilliant screen can handle your IoT gadgets, stream games, and that’s just the beginning

Samsung is adding onto its setup of brilliant screens with the 4K 32-inch M8....

By admin
Starfield Trends as Fans Call it Their Most Anticipated Xbox Game of 2022 News

Starfield Trends as Fans Call it Their Most Anticipated Xbox Game of 2022

Starfield Trends Their Starfield Trends 2022 The beginning of another year implies that new...

By admin